Poster art of the film’s extensive character cast

(9) ZOOTOPIA

(ZOOTOPIA 1-2 2016-2025 – yes, I’m anticipating the sequel)

Who doesn’t love anthropomorphic animals? Of course, Zootopia is a whole world exclusively of anthropomorphic animals (and it won’t be the only such world in my top ten animated films), a world very much like ours but with every other mammal in our place.

Although…when you take it too seriously (and I take my fictional worlds way too seriously), Zootopia is not quite the utopia its name suggests. As Cracked has pointed out, for the sake of a few rabbit sex jokes, Zootopia is about to go post-apocalyptic from total ecological collapse – in about a week or so. “Zootopia is a movie about the brief halcyon days of an imperious city as it remains wilfully blind to its inevitable doom”.

Alternatively, as I have mused before, is The Island of Doctor Moreau the grim backstory of Zootopia? You know, after he unleashed his army of beast-men and women on an unsuspecting humanity…

But enough of that – Zootopia is a film that is equally cute, funny and heartwarming, a “3D computer animated buddy cop comedy mystery adventure film” as cute protagonist rabbit police officer Judy Hopps, pairs up with slick fox con artist Nick Wilde.

The animation is lush and visually spectacular – they developed fur-controlling software (iGroom) – with thoughtful themes for the contemporary society the animal world reflects.

I’m looking forward to the sequel film coming out in 2025.

FANTASY OR SF

Well perhaps SF with some extensive genetic engineering but I’m going to rank this as fantasy – classic beast fable mode!

COMEDY

Definitely a comedy – from the odd couple protagonists to gags on animal characteristics as adapted to what would otherwise be an human urban environment.

RATING: 4 STARS****

A-TIER (TOP-TIER)

(10) THE WILD ROBOT

(DREAMWORKS: 2024)

The Wild Robot is my wildcard tenth place entry for top animated film of 2024.

I mean, it’s essentially Robinson Crusoe with a robot as protagonist, isn’t it? Or is that Tarzan with a robot protagonist, given that Robinson Crusoe doesn’t interact with the animals of his island as peers (and is more Puritan)?

There’s something about the premise of shipwreck or similar circumstances returning us to a state of nature. The Wild Robot goes one step further returning our technological doppelganger to that state of nature, although I have questions with respect to what seems to be a significant problem with robot supply chains in the film.

It also has the added charm of a machine effectively becoming one of the animals on her new island home – which to me has the surprising philosophical depth of combining the two main counterpoints to humanism of comparing (or contrasting) humans to animals and to our machines. (I’ve got the body of an animal and the mind of a machine).

Anyway, robot Robinson Crusoe is essentially the premise of the film in a nutshell – service robot Roz (voiced by Lupita Nyong’o) is shipwrecked or washed up on an island and learns to survive in the wilderness among the local wildlife.

It was commercially and critically successful – “praised for its story, themes, animation, score, emotional depth, and voice acting” while apparently Dreamworks’ most nominated film at the Academy Awards.

I was surprised when looking up the film to learn that it was based on a book (for children and teenagers) – indeed a book trilogy, so it was not surprising to also learn that a sequel film is in development.

FANTASY OR SF

Well, the robot in the title gives it away as SF, although it has elements of animal fable.

COMEDY

Mostly of the fish out of water variety – or robot on the island.

RATING:

X-TIER (WILD TIER) – BEST OF 2024

“Steamboat Willie” – the animated short film that was the debut film distributed for Disney’s Mickey Mouse and one of the first cartoons with synchronized sound – now in public domain!

TOP 10 ANIMATED FILMS

Animation is my favorite medium, albeit more for TV series than film – my favorite TV series are always animated TV series. However, animated films aren’t far behind as there’s something about the animated medium that seems to retain creativity beyond the point where live-action medium counterparts exhausts it.

Of course, part of that might be the advantage the animated medium has in being able to depict things on screen through its definitive animation of art, which can only be replicated in the live-action medium, if at all, through practical or CGI effects. For me, live-action CGI effects still lag behind their animated counterparts, even that of digital animation – ironically both in terms of realism seamlessly with the live action components on screen and the emotional expressiveness of depiction. An example of the latter is that of animals, where animated art can depict them with more human-like features or expressions. For me, that was one of the issues with the recent Disney trend of live action remakes of their animated films. If your live action remake needs to be substantially or predominantly CGI to replicate the original animation or its characters, then you are essentially substituting one form of animation for another – and an inferior one at that.

Another part of my enjoyment of animated films – and hence my separate top ten for them – following from the above is their versatility for depicting fantasy or science fiction. The medium of animation seems ideally suited to fantasy or SF, perhaps even more so than the live-action film medium – except for the human attachment to seeing the human actors on screen, rather than hearing their voices from their animated avatars. Hence, my Top 10 Animated Films is effectively a subset of my Top 10 Fantasy & SF Films, as each entry is either fantasy or SF and I will note the extent of each entry as such. As a general rule, animated films lean towards fantasy, while films adapted from comics (for which I have a separate top ten) lean towards SF.

They also tend to be comedic in nature, with the animated medium being ideal for visual as well as verbal humor – such that they might also effectively be a subset of my Top 10 Comedy Films and again I will note the extent of each entry as comedy.

Anyway, these are my Top 10 Animated Films.